Assalamu alaikum, now that it *really* is Eid, well in most of the world anyway, what do we do now? I mean, IMHO, something has to be done, though I don’t know exactly what at the moment. Yusuf has some good ideas, and there are some good ideas here, however, how is dialogue going to work when those of us who continue to question the early sightings which almost always come out of Saudi Arabia, year after year, and where, as a result of this, it is later determined in many cases (1, 2, 3, 4), though pretty quietly it seems, to have been a “mistake”, are told we are “weak in faith”?
IMHO, if the same people keep making the same mistakes, many years in a row, shouldn’t we question them? Shouldn’t they be considered as unreliable? Especially if this issue has been brought to their attention and the best they can say is “if you question us you’re weak in faith”, or your Islam is deficient, or whatever. How many times does one have to make a mistake before their testimony for moon sighting can be rejected?
As uncomfortable as I am with the announcements coming out of Saudi Arabia and other places, I’m most certainly not going to question the faith, the very Islam, of the people who choose to follow those sightings. Just as I don’t want my faith to be questioned if I *don’t* follow those sightings and choose to follow people that seem to be more reliable.
The issue for me is not so much that people follow Saudi Arabia, it’s just that Saudi gets it wrong almost every year! And until either people start realizing this, or until Saudi changes their criteria somehow, and until people who follow something different aren’t told their “deficient in faith”, we’re all going to go through this year after year.
I’m trying to figure out a way to follow what I feel, based on my knowledge and comfort level, to be correct, yet not causing fitna for the rest of the community, which would be attending the Eid prayers, for example, yet still continuing to fast. But it’s kinda hard to be discreet if people are pushing plates into your hands *smile*. Perhaps having stomach issues is a blessing in this case as I can’t really eat terribly early in the mornings anyway.
I just feel hurt, angry, and offended that my very faith in Allah and His Will has been questioned (not to mention the implied accusations by some of having some sort of agenda), because of my incredulity at being told midafternoon on Monday that “Eid was tomorrow”. And no, I did not, nor would I, go screaming to my community that they were “wrong” for doing Eid on Tuesday. I shared my discomfort with a select few, at least 2,878 to be exact, if this blog stat thing is anything to go by. So I guess it’s not a select few, but I’m talking about offline, I only spoke of this to some people.
I mean, is it so bad to have a difference of opinion and not be accused of “not using the Qur’an and Sunnah as your guide”, etc., or “relying too much on science”.
So I say something has to be done, I say that more people need to be educated regarding this issue, but how far are you going to get when your aqeedah is called into question if you don’t take every moon sighting report you hear as credible?
What I’m planning to do, Inshallah, is try to make moon sighting possibilities/projections available on this blog, from whatever various organizations I can find, shortly before the 29th day of every month, keeping in mind that the current month could have started on at least two different days. Then, once the moon has been sighted, I will post those reports again from the various organizations who collect and make available this information. I will also try to post any relevant articles, links, etc., regarding this issue, including but by no means not limited to any reports of “errors” or “mistakes” in the beginning or ending of certain Islamic months.
The little best I can do, regarding this issue, is to make as much information available to people, in one place, as I can, and let people read and make up their own mind. That is the best I can do., Inshallah