Responding to Umar Lee’s Post Regarding “Keeping Quiet”
Assalamu alaikum, Umar Lee responded to my post regarding “keeping quiet”, so I wanted to respond back, in a better way than I felt I could do in the comments area of his blog. So here goes…
“Muslim or non-Muslim if you are white you will always be looked at as a racist by most African-Americans and a lot of other people of color”
Umar, I do think you are right about this. And while us “white people” can get upset about this, most likely, 9 times out of 10, most people of color would be well within their rights to suspect most white people of harboring some sort of prejudice toward them. Sadly, I just think it’s ingrained somehow in “white culture” or “whiteness” or some sort of “white privilege” or “white superiority” or something. I don’t know if this grew out of Europe’s feeling of superiority toward other people/continents or not, and thus, was transported over to America during its colonization or not. However, this is the sad fact. I’ll say that I feel that most white people are prejudiced in some way, though not all are what you’d call a raving white power racist either. And to find a white person who has not been “tainted” shall we say, is few and far between. I think, though, that you have many white people who recognize this prejudicial quality within themselves, and Inshallah, are striving to rid themselves of it. I think sometimes, we are prejudiced though we don’t realize it, and it happens without us realizing it. Though we all know the overt cases of learned prejudice, etc., and the fact that many people *are* prejudiced, and you find people who either don’t want to admit it, as it is currently not politically correct to do so, (well unless it’s against Muslims anyway), or you have the white supremacist groups/people who don’t care what is “politically correct”. I’m reminded that at one time, the KKK had something like millions of members? though not sure of the exact number, I think this was in the 1930’s, and that kind of “hatred” just doesn’t disappear! I don’t think.
“and this can be extended to Muslims from places such as Gambia or Bangladesh or whatever. If you are working in any advocacy group for any of these countries you are
there to cheerlead and assist them, not to be a dissenting or critical voice (and if you are you will be reminded you are a white devil whose job it is
to fell guilty and support whatever they have to say no matter how illogical).”
Umar, I also think you make a good point about this as well. And throw in “colonialism/colonizer” in the mix, you get called that too! Even though you didn’t colonize anyone, at least to your knowledge, though “your people” may have. And you are right, your job is to “agree” with the dominant opinion, even if some of that group hold your same opinion. And even if the descenting opinions within that group get criticized, they still have more of a “right” to hold differing opinions than the “dominant one”, because they are still a member of that particular group. For example, if you are talking about Gambian politics, when the opposition coalition, which was formed before the last Presidential election, broke up, you had those who criticized the largest opposition party for breaking up/leaving the coalition, and this “criticism” tended to be the majority opinion on the lists that I was on, though perhaps many people who were in favor of the split just didn’t speak up. At any rate, those who were in favor of the split, including myself, were labelled all sorts of things, i.e., power-hungry, tribalist, selfish, not having the Gambian people’s best interests at heart, and in the case of myself, colonizer, etc., got thrown in their too. However, organizations which were set up to assist in fund-raising and otherwise assist in the effort to “restore democracy in The Gambia”, had no problem taking money, aid, or other forms of assistance from interested non-Gambians. We just had to be careful either to have the “right opinion”, or to be quiet and just not say anything at all, if our opinions differed from the “vocal” dominant opinion. Now, I’ll say that every time I say this, every time I’ve mentioned this publicly, inevitably, I’ll have some Gambians right me or speak to me privately and say something along the lines of “you’re saying everything I want to say, but I can’t or won’t say it, because I don’t want them to criticize or bad mouth me, thank you for speaking up, you’re courageous”, etc., or if it’s not that, it’s “I really do agree with you, but I don’t have time to respond to these people”. And when I tell them that I will no longer comment on these issues, that I think it’s better for me, on so many levels, to no longer speak out, I’m told not to let anyone stop me, to keep talking, that I do indeed have a right to speak up, that, based on my steadfast “support and love of Gambians” that I’ve shown in the past, I’ve “earned my right to speak”.
Well, personally, I do not believe this! Firstly, I don’t want to speak for people who seem, for whatever reason, to not want to speak for themselves! And secondly, I just plain feel it’s not my place to do so! Because the negative reactions, the name-calling, the hatemail, etc., are all I need to tell me that it’s not my place, the few people who quietly tell me otherwise notwithstanding. I feel like just because *you* don’t want to speak up, doesn’t mean that I should be pushed to the front to do so, to take the “slings and arrows”, as it were, that you don’t want to take. And even if it was deemed “my place”, the negativity is just toxic to me! You also have a third group of people, who, rather than engage in endless debates and arguments on online fora, have decided to work quietly behind-the-scenes to try to affect some sort of change. Some people in this group would fall into the second group I’ve described above, encouraging me to “keep speaking out”, yet others, while acknowledging that my opinions may indeed be valid, that “it is not worth wasting your time on these people”. And while they are telling you this, they are saying things like “I know these people, I know how they are”, etc., etc. And while I feel validated by people who come and say “yeah, you’re right”, etc., or something along those lines, the fact that “they know these people”, and they have personal insights into the people, topics, discussions, etc., that you, as a non-Gambian, could never have, being that you’re not a member of that group, further demonstrates to me, that I really should just shut up, ’cause I just don’t have any idea what I’m talking about anyway. Yusuf made a comment on the related post to this topic, and the message that I got from it was that being married to a Gambian somehow gave me a right to involvement / discussion in these issues. And I just don’t know how true that is! I can talk to my husband about these issues, and he knows where I’m coming from, and I could possibly share my opinion with a few others, but not on a public forum, at least not anymore.
“Your job is to be the white mascot and it helps if you have money to donate to the cause.”
Absolutely, see my comments above regarding this. For many Gambians, non-Gambians (and this actually extends to *any* non-Gambian, including African-Americans), can give money, we can make T-shirts, bumper stickers, we can put together fund-raising events, but just don’t be too vocal about what you think, or at least, as I said above, don’t have the *wrong* opinion.
“It is difficult to see how anyone can maintain any self-respect while playing this role”
I’d also agree with you here as well. It makes me anyway, feel used. Why should I give my money / aid / support to a cause where I’m not allowed to participate fully? But sure, my money, time, resources, etc., are sure put to use? It always made me angry that my money was sure taken in a hurry, but every time I’d open my mouth, it seemed the same people who’d taken my money last week, last month, or last year, were the first ones to jump up and chastize me for “chatting about Gambian issues”, as one commentor put it. Yes, it is hard to play this role, and I refuse to play it any longer!
” and I think it is a losing battle to ever try and
convince non-whites, especially blacks, you are not racist,”
Yes, you are probably right here, too, though I’d say that it would depend on how well you “know” the people you are trying to “convince”. I think if you really know someone, and they see you, your actions, what you say about others, etc., you don’t have to “convince” them of anything. They *know* that you are not racist. However, if you just start talking to someone you don’t know that well, then yes, you’re going to have a hard time convincing them that you’re not racist/prejudiced in some way.
” and I am not going to sit around and patronize some group of morons out of some sense of white
guilt.”
I’d agree with you here as well, although speaking for myself, my interest in Gambian issues, which seems to be the topic here, came about as something altogether different than “white guilt”. However, I can see how others would get that impression, and I don’t think I can do anything, nor do I think I *should* do anything to change that. My problem is thta I try to hard to pelase everyone! It bothers me when people are angry with or upset with me! And this is just something that I need to work on. You’re not going to please everyone all of the time, and at any rate, the goal should be pleasing Allah, trying to be a good Muslim, trying to do right by others, and I want to say speaking out / trying to do something about injustice where I see it. But as noted above, you’ve got to be careful agint htis!
As the Presidential and Parliamentary elections are over, and it seems that the majority of Gambians are happy with Yahya Jammeh and the APRC party, as a non-Gambian, there isn’t much more I can do regaridng this. Why am I to tell the seeming majority of Gambians who voted for this guy that they are wrong? Yes, personally, I feel this guy is wrong. The use of Islam to “mystify himself”, his supposed “ability” to cure HIV/AIDS, asthma, and supposedly other diseases, among many other things, as a Muslim, and just an ordinary person, is sickening to me! However, there is *nothing* that I can do about it! And now that the elections are over, if I keep “speaking out”, then it would look as though “I’m telling Gambians what to do”. It has come to a point that I, as a non-Gambian, really can’t do anymore! Becuase then it would look as though I was imposing my will on someone else, and especially so being that I’m white.
Regarding “white guilt”, I think that we, as white people, need to strike a balance between recognizing racism, prejudice, and white previlege, where it exists, and work to change those things, yet at the same time temper that “white guilt”, which makes us make fools of ourselves, in trying to do anything other than “be white”, either by “trying to be something else”, or whatever. Allah made you who you are and denying your “whiteness”, Americanness” or whatever, would be denying Allah, in some way, because He willed who you would be, where you’d be born, etc. I don’t think this world was ever meant to be easy, no matter who you are, so you just need to make the best of it, try to be the best Muslim you can be, and strive to please Allah, as on the Day of Judgment, that is the only thing that will matter.