Assalamu alaikum / greetings, OK so I think I’m finally going to “take the plunge” as it were, and get a second Leader Dog!
Actually, oddly enough, a sister at the masjid a while back asked if I was ever going to get another dog, this is after I’d told her about Abby. I said yes that I would like to, and of course, she added the caviot of “oh be careful because if she touches your clothes, you’ll have to wash them”, etc. And I didn’t even argue, I just nodded and said, “OK”, differences of opinion being a mercy and all. I wasn’t even going to go into the “the Maliki madhhab says, thus and such”, etc. Because what is the point? The sister meant well, and the fact that she even thought I *should* get a dog was a refreshing change from the usual, “why can’t your husband just help you” stuff I normally hear when the topic of getting a second dog is brought up.
The fact is, I don’t want to “rely on my husband for everything”. Perhaps this wouldn’t matter so much to a sighted woman, or perhaps it wouldn’t matter so much to other blind women, but my independence does matter a lot to me. And asking “why”, in an incredulous tone, or saying “why can’t your husband just help you”, or waxing on and on about “angels not entering a house with a dog in it”, or “you’ll losing X amount of reward a day of you keep a dog”, when the issue of getting a second dog is brought up, well, at the very least irritates me! And at the most, Astaghfirullah, makes me angry! Because it’s so easy to talk about “your husband helping you” or “angels not entering the house”, etc., or “you’d better not get a second dog because you’ll have a hard time finding a husband if you do”, when you, presumably as a sighted person, take your independence for granted. It’s so easy to talk like this when you can look outside, walk across the street, or down the street, to anywhere you want to go. Or, get in a car and drive to get there.
But Allah did not will for me to have that experience! For me, learning the skills needed to travel independently took years for me to learn, and not only to learn, but to master and to build up the self-confidence needed to be able to travel independently.
And although I do know that in some cases, in Islam there may be restrictions placed on women’s travel, etc., as a blind person, I find myself bawking at these restrictions. Because as a blind person, a house can be just as much of a prison as any jail can be, without the requisite skills to be able to walk out, and be able to go from Point A to Point B by myself. OK, OK, so I’m digressing. Just suffice it to say that I take my independence very seriously, and unless you have been in a position where you have had to fight for it, where it isn’t taken for granted because you possess functional use of all of your senses, well, I hate to sound cliche here, but it would be difficult for you to understand unless you yourself have had to go through something like this.
The fact is, the way I was raised, my mom used to tell me that I had to learn to do as much for myself as possible because “there isn’t always going to be someone around to do it for you”. And even though I am married now, and have a husband who would readily do something for me if I needed it, the fact is he isn’t always going to be around should I need something. Let’s say he travels, let’s say something happens to him (may Allah protect him from that), let’s just say he’s gone out for the day. And let’s say I need to run to the store. Let’s say I want to walk to the park. What am I going to do?
Of course, I could just use a cane, and for many blind people, that is sufficient. But frankly for me, it is not. I have had the privilege of using a dog for ten years, and I must say that having a dog with you, as opposed to a cane, there is a level of confidence and independence that I feel that for me anyway, surpasses the use of a cane.
And what is sad about all of this is that not only do I feel I have to defend my decision to acquire a Leader Dog with the “you’re not a “normal blind person”, if you use a dog” or “you’re not truly an independent traveler” crowd of the blind/visually impaired community, I feel I also have to defend my decision with Muslims as well.
And to be honest, I’m tired of it, and I’m inclined to say that I will not defend my mobility choices as a blind woman, anymore than I’ll defend my choice to wear hijab, my choice to follow a madhhab, or my choice of tariqa, not to mention my choice to be a Muslim at all. Although having said that, sadly, I probably will fall into the “having to defend yourself” trap at some point.
And sometimes it seems that being blind can clash with being Muslim, the dog guide users vs. taxi cab drivers’ debate comes to mind. I remember one time having to explain to a blind man, non-Muslim, who uses a dog guide, the issues faced by taxi drivers who may consider dogs unclean. And this guy I was speaking to was not buying any of my explanations. And now that I think about it, he probably shouldn’t have. I don’t see why the said taxi drivers couldn’t take some sort of dispensation, or something, if they were in the position where they had to carry dog guides in their cab with them. I mean, it seems that *no Muslim*, unless they follow the Maliki madhhab, are even aware of the opinion of the dog being pure, and even if they are they will talk of the “weakness of the opinion”, etc. However, if people are looking for the “easy way out” on things like hijab, riba, selling alcohol, tobacco, and pork, etc., then why can’t they do the same when it comes to the issue of dog guides.
I also remember a few years ago, asking a blind Muslim sister, who also happens to be a dog guide user, if CAIR had addressed this issue, and the answer, at the time was, no, they had not. And why not? Because I will tell you that if I am ever denied a taxi ride by a Muslim on the basis of my Leader Dog, I’m telling you I will challenge it as far as I can, because there is *no reason* why he/she could not take me in their cabs! None! Surely some sort of education can be done, surely cabbies could carry some sort of mat or blanket to put on the floor where the dog is trained to lay during a car ride, which could be easily washed later or something.
But anyway, my whole point is that as a blind woman, I will not give up my independence, because you just never know when you will need it! Because as my mother said, “there isn’t always going to be someone around to hold your hand and do things for you, so you have to learn to do as much for yourself as you can.”
Another issue that just occurred to me is the issue of going to the masjid. Well, guess I won’t be doing that any time soon, well, once I get the dog anyway. Because during the first 6 months to a year or so, it is not a good idea to leave your dog when going out if at all possible, as they are new, and you and them are still in the bonding process. Perhaps if my masjid was a bit bigger, I could put my dog off to the side on a tie-down chain or something, but being that the women’s area is like the size of a small bedroom or something, I don’t see where I could put the dog where they would be out of the way, and I’d not want to leave them outside or leave them in the car. And this is not to even talk of the other people’s reaction to the dog even being in the masjid in the first place. So *sigh*, another reason *not* to go to the masjid. But anyway.
I would also be curious to know if any imams/masjid leaders have had to address this sort of accommodation or not. But another topic for another day as it is Dhuhr time now. I’d be interested in hearing everyone’s thoughts on this, good or bad, pro or con, positive or negative. I don’t know if Umar Lee is a reader of this blog or not, but if he isn’t, could someone point him in this direction? I’d really like his thoughts on this issue. Has he had a dog guide user in his cab? If so, how did he handle it? Does he take any special precautions when a service dog is in his cab, if he has had to deal with this issue? Would he refuse to take a person with a service dog? If so, why? I’d be interested to hear his thoughts on the issue.